Questions tagged [specific-question]
The specific-question tag has no usage guidance.
45
questions
3
votes
1answer
40 views
Was annotating and deleting a answer at the same time intended?
This answer was annotated as needing sources and deleted by a single vote at the same time.
I agree adding sources would improve it, but it seems a bit heavy handed.
0
votes
1answer
116 views
Plain language and clear and helpful explanation of what if anything is wrong with this April 2019 question
Most challenging aspects of a reusable satellite scheme like this? was posted in April 2019. There is now a collection of evolving complaints below it in comments that to me feel as though they are ...
0
votes
2answers
85 views
ICBM and space-related weapons questions have been on-topic, why change now?
The following few examples demonstrate that the topics of ICBMs and space-related weapons can be well-received on this site:
How to decide if the rocket most recently tested by North Korean is ...
2
votes
1answer
38 views
Should I rewrite my question to fit the upvoted answer that didn't address my question and then post the original as a new question?
My question Have light gases like hydrogen or helium been explored for ion propulsion? reiterates the question in the body of the text:
Has the "ion sorcery" for light gases like hydrogen and ...
0
votes
2answers
67 views
Repeated false-flag comments and votes, how to respond/reply?
I'm faced with a user who picks a small element of my question, posts an "answer" as a comment and (likely) down votes, and sometimes will vote to close as duplicate of something which does not answer ...
1
vote
0answers
34 views
Eleven community wiki answers to a question?
The "oldie but goodie" question What are the choices today for orbital mechanics simulation software? has eleven separate community wiki answers (more if you count the deleted ones).
Questions:
...
0
votes
1answer
67 views
When exactly was the solenoid question reopened?
The question Electromagnetic lens to focus cosmic rays was rapidly closed and then reopened.
I've tried that new timeline thingy on the left (below the voting buttons) and I can see when closing ...
9
votes
2answers
409 views
Should nonsensical question titles be edited?
Recently this question was posted: Is the ISS a tennis racket?
I think the question itself is good, but the question title by itself does not make any sense without context. This makes it useless in ...
3
votes
2answers
132 views
Do I police this site as if it were my own?
This comment says:
@uhoh: That's good for you. It is very unclear to me, because your interpretation doesn't make sense, as other comments have pointed out. Not objective indeed, maybe you should ...
2
votes
1answer
82 views
What is it about this question that makes people want to close it despite the engineering-based answers?
The question How well could the Tesla Cybertruck drive on Mars? received five close votes and was put on hold, then re-opened, and now currently has four more close votes, for a total of nine, most or ...
1
vote
1answer
46 views
Why is this question about science on Venus off-topic?
Why is the question With no acid cloud deck surrounding Venus, would the poles be much colder than the equator ? put on hold as off-topic?
Isn't the question about planetary science and as such on-...
3
votes
0answers
59 views
Why was this question so quickly put on hold, and without comments, guidance, or suggestions?
What does this NASA administrator's tweeted statement mean? What is the context?
Question: Would a similar statement about taxpayer money used in SLS/Boeing or the JWST (delays and cost overruns ...
2
votes
1answer
48 views
Why was my flagging a Dunning-Kruger effect comment declined?
I flagged the comment:
"Most of the things are done." No they're not. Not even close. You are so far from being done that it is impossible to know just how incredibly far from being done ...
11
votes
3answers
379 views
What question concerning KSP are on topic?
Give the comments in this question Will Kerbal Space Program 2 have Lagrange points, halo orbits, and other 3-body goodies?, I wander what questions related to KSP are on topic.
I propose the ...
1
vote
1answer
45 views
When the real answer may only be in links within comments below the answer, what to do or say?
This answer to What radio frequencies were used by the Soviet space program circa 1961? (“Lost Cosmonaut” recording) contains a lot of relevant perspective, and is authored by a user who regularly ...
11
votes
5answers
212 views
Why edit other people's posts and undo their use of in-line links?
A new user performed a substantial suggested edit to another user's answer post, changing all the in-line links to numbered links with the urls themselves moved to the bottom of the post. I rejected ...
2
votes
0answers
26 views
Should one of these be closed as a duplicate of the other? If so, which one?
Two well written, well received questions each with several well written, well received answers. Each now has one close vote as a duplicate of the other.
January 2019 Why are probes that tend to ...
2
votes
1answer
31 views
Okay if I re-ask this Space Exploration-related question from Astronomy SE here?
The well-received question in Astronomy SE What is the maximum transmission distance of the radio signal in the outer space which could still be understood? was asked in November of 2013 and so is way ...
2
votes
1answer
33 views
Are second-person edits supposed to push a question to the main page?
A new user asked "When do rockets push back on matter?", which as originally written seemed to push a particular point of view, rather than pose a genuine question. It subsequently garnered a large ...
1
vote
0answers
46 views
Example of dysfunctional question closing and answering?
There are good, thorough answers that can not be posted to the question Time taken for moon landing because the question is currently closed.
This is because @JanDoggen voted to close as duplicate ...
0
votes
0answers
15 views
Are these questions good candidates for merging?
There are two overlapping questions, each with one or more good quality and well-received answer.
Are there any CubeSats that have been launched into Geostationary (GEO/GSO) or Geostationary Transfer ...
1
vote
0answers
26 views
Were the moderators flagged by this user's “minor” edits? Did they find it irritating?
The question Who did I irritate enough for someone to mass downvote some of my answers? has a few answers, and discussion in comments under one of them suggest that the user's edits could be "...
1
vote
2answers
70 views
Is this question truly off-topic? Or are people just (over) reacting to the “may be better suited” comment?
The author of the comment addressed to me
This may be better suited to a geology or physics site.
says they didn't vote to close, but the comment seems to have none-the-less triggered some ...
2
votes
3answers
102 views
Is my answer being sabotaged?
I propose the following:
The block quoted text in the question Can someone help Scott Manley explain this capture maneuver? is inarticulate and pretty much meaningless in terms of explaining ...
2
votes
2answers
78 views
Is voting to close of this question warranted or at least defensible, or was this a bit reckless?
The question What were some of the first two stage rockets flown? has just been put on hold as duplicate to When did the concept of “stages” enter rocketry?.
I feel this was a bit of reckless voting,...
1
vote
1answer
35 views
Combustion chamber question on topic?
What Constitutes A Combustion Chamber?
We don't 'do' fuel questions, but what about this one?
Should it be closed or is it 'innocent' enough?
I lean towards accepting it.
Related meta: Why can't ...
4
votes
3answers
219 views
“Please invent my invention” or “Would X work?” questions; suitability and topicality?
For comparison, what a "good" i.e. well researched "Would X work?" reactor question might look like:
Could a “nuclear turbo-jet” be built?
Example 1 (as originally posted):
The ...
-5
votes
3answers
68 views
Is the anonymous, silent down-vote plus close-vote for “unclear” on a new user's question welcoming?
This question was recently posted. Within 8 minutes two users responded:
I found some resources for the OP and left a link, then edited the question to improve the grammar. I felt the question was ...
0
votes
1answer
29 views
Should these two tidal forces questions be asked in Astronomy SE instead of here?
Two questions just asked:
How do we know that an exoplanet is tidally locked to the parent star?
Do tides occur on planets like Neptune, having water?
while probably not off-topic here, are ...
2
votes
2answers
126 views
Is this question really, truly off-topic while all of these other physics questions are on-topic?
The question Two 1000 kg gold spheres orbit their CM in near-contact, great way to measure G or limited by spaceflight issues? was put on hold for being off topic. It seems that using a spacecraft to ...
2
votes
1answer
92 views
Are third party robots editing my posts and removing my sentences?
The comment on this edit says:
Comment: broken image fixed (click 'rendered output' to see the difference); for more info, see https://gist.github.com/Glorfindel83/9d954d34385d2ac2597bbe864466259f
...
3
votes
2answers
64 views
Why delete a question with so many well-written and received answers?
The question Why does the Mars InSight Lander look wet like a cardboard box that came in contact with water? [closed] may have a conspiracy theorist bent but it was handled well and has three very ...
2
votes
2answers
75 views
Why should the question below be closed when there is no specific answer to it?
The question "Does a credible Kármán plane reach escape velocity within 1 minute or does it follow the curvature of the Earth ?" was closed because it would have an answer from the already closed ...
6
votes
1answer
215 views
How many variants of the “Was Karman wrong?” question is enough for one user?
In addition to my answer there, I've just added the comment
-1 "If von Kármán is right with his description of the Kármán line..." That sentence misrepresents ...
1
vote
1answer
63 views
How to get a link to an old question of mine, possibly deleted?
I am looking for an old question of mine that (I believe) asked about the largest number of different kinds of satellites in one payload. I also believe I included a yellow-room photo of the Kanopus-V-...
2
votes
2answers
68 views
Is voting to close a question for “primarily opinion-based answers” while answering with fact exercising faulty logic, or even gamesmanship?
The question Will Scotland require a space agency? Is there one in the works? was insta-closed, but not before one of the closers also wrote a well-received, fact-based answer to it.
I find the logic ...
-1
votes
2answers
61 views
What might these silent close-voters' reasons have been? How might I address them?
I just wrote the comment:
This question asks about decisions made within the US government and so can have a factual answer. Insta-closing prevents such answers from being written. I am not ...
1
vote
3answers
82 views
Bad physics in accepted answer, what to do? (if anything)
This answer is currently accepted. I believe the physics is wrong, since conservation of angular momentum prevents a satellite from raising its orbit around a spherically symmetric body by using only ...
4
votes
3answers
266 views
Answering “What would happen to the ISS if we stopped maintaining it”
Feel free to post information relevant to answering What would happen to the ISS if we stopped maintaining it below:
2
votes
1answer
68 views
What's the purpose of the “Post is related to a rapidly changing event.” label on my question?
My question Could Steve have hurt the ISS? has a type of comment added that I haven't seen before. The text is Post is related to a rapidly changing event.
Is ...
0
votes
2answers
48 views
Truth vs Presentation
In this question some feedback made me wonder,
what matters more in an answer, truth or presentation style?
1
vote
0answers
34 views
How to improve the question about the design of the controller in lunar lander?
Criticism on the UX of the control panel of the lunar module
I'm not new to SE, but new to here. This question is closed as unclear, and well, I agree with that. The question comes from my poor ...
3
votes
1answer
56 views
Are questions based on conceptual (almost speculative) projects on-topic?
I have a question that is practical, but based on a speculative project.
I would like to know the effects on humans and cargo traveling on your standard, hypothetical space elevator of 100k km, ...
5
votes
1answer
103 views
Why was this question downvoted? How might I get it answered?
Inviting from the community your guidance, suggestions, opinions, and theories as to why this question was downvoted and close-voted:
How long would it take to move Venus and Mars into Earth's ...
4
votes
1answer
68 views
What should be done when information learned later largely invalidates a question?
I asked "Why did the ESA choose SPARC for LEON?" and nos pointed out that SPARC was used for the ESA's previous 32-bit processors.
With a 32-bit ISA already in use, the continued use of SPARC makes ...
